Benefit

Badgal Bang 24hr Eye Pencil Eyeliner

I am so missing the original bad gal liner waterproof pencil. Why did you replace it with the bad gal bang? At least give those of us who were the original buyers a choice. Very disappointing.

I have this in brown - it's hard to find a good brown, some are too light, some are reddish looking, this one is the brown that i want. After having used it for some time, mine got dull and the lines were starting to come out too wide since it wasn't sharp. It doesn't have a built in sharpener and so i tried to use my own sharpener on it - lightly. Half of the pencil ended up breaking off. I reached out to customer service to see about a refund and ask how they recommend sharpening it. The sharpening question was not answered and I was instructed to return it to the store i bought it from. Which I can't do since i no longer have the receipt since i've had it for a while. If the sharpening issue could be fixed i'd recommend it.

This is my go-to liner. What's with all the bad reviews? It's the perfect quick and easy liner for the days you want to look put together, without a lot of hassle. It goes on easy, has plenty of color pay-off, can be smudged with the other end, and stays on all day (and yeah, I need to use oil based cleanser to completely remove it!) I love the brown, it's the best I've found, a true dark brown. Love the purple too, it's subtle and goes with my rose and smoky purple shadows. I'm not a talented makeup artist, and this is so forgiving, so you can make a subtle line without a lot of "mess ups". And that smudger at the end really helps with the mistakes. I reserve the black for my "going out" more dramatic looks. Its great for travel too as you don't need a sharpener. Please don't ever stop making this or I'll have to buy tons to stock up for a couple of years until I find something else I like.

I have been sad for years, thinking that Benefit discontinued their kohl pencil (with a smudger). (I knew that the BadGal Bang existed in black, but I'm a dark brown type of eyeliner person.) The other day I was literally moping around the Benefit section of Ulta and saw that this eyeliner now (or always did?) came in black, brown, purple, and blue! I was going to order the brown online when I decided to try the purple tester to see how it applied. I actually really like it (I have greenish hazel eyes that seem to change color and can look grey) and bought it. I've been using it for a week now and will be buying it in brown and maybe blue and black... So, anyone looking for a replacement for Benefit's Kohl Eyeliner pencil, this is it! It's better than the Lancome or either of the Clinique eyeliners that come with the smudge sponge. I like to soften my eyeliner a bit, so the smudge sponge is a must for me.

Having worn the Bad Gal eye pencil comfortably with my contact lenses for years, now this has sadly been discontinued I gave this liner a try. It glides on easliy but does not stay on at all well, leaving eyes looking messy and needing constant retouching throughout the day. It is not suitable for contact lens wearers or sensitive eyes as it causes irritation.

I never write reviews but this one was quite disappointing. The eyeliner is so thick and hard to work with. The smudge thing doesn't work at all! (and is very stiff). In my opinion, it was too pricey for such quality. I'm not a professional MUA, but if you aren't going for a messy eye look that you cannot control, I wouldn't recommend this product :/

My eyeliner arrived today and the box the liner was inside was already open on both ends. Then when I tried to test it out, there was no liner coming out at all. I tried twisting it in case some had broken off during the its journey here, but still nothing was being produced. Very poor quality.

Thank you for making something great for fair skinned, blue eyed women! I love it, goes on easy and the color is great, not navy blue but a mid-blue! Years ago you have a Tuxedo blue that I loved but it disappeared, hope you keep this one. How about adding a copper color? thank you, Benefit!