Benefit

Roller Eye Bright Highlighter Pencil Eyeliner

The color of this pencil was strange at best. It looked like I had smeared light peach concealer in my inner lash line, and created an effect of hyperpigmentation where the pencil wasn't. I have fair skin, too. It sucked all of the moisture from my eyes, and I couldn't wait to get it off. 15 hours later and my eyes are still burning. I do not have sensitive skin or reactions to much of anything. I love Benefit, but this product is a FAIL.

The original eye bright pencil was a must have for me, really brightened the eyes without being a stark pure white. This however, is terrible. It's actually darker than my skin tone, and a lot warmer in tone than my waterline. It actually does the opposite of what it's supposed to for me. It make my eyes look smaller and sore... I'm really going to miss the original eye bright.

Very sad they did away with Eye Bright pencil. and then replace it with this is very disappointing. Once other reviewer asked why do away with something that isn't broken? I'd REALLY like to have the Eye Bright pencil back. I have since moved to Thrive's products and found a better replacement than this 'rubbish' (per another reviewer).

I have been a fan of the original eye brightening pencil for years. This is a poor substitute for the original eye brightening pencil, and ridiculous price.. Scratches and irritates when it goes on, it is so hard it is impossible to blend. First time ever I am throwing out a benefit product. Bring back the original

If I could give this zero I would. I loved the original eye bright pencil which was a pale pink & went on a dream. This is a very poor substitute. Totally different colour, more peachy. Hardly even goes on as its a harder formula. Complete waste of money & I'd actually stocked up with an extra one too

Since the Eye Bright Pencil was retired, I've stopped using all Benefit products. The Eye Bright Pencil was the best pencil ever. Please bring it back. The pencil that so called replaced the Eye Bright Pencil is junk and does not work.

Bright orange, not like the gorgeous eyebright pencil which is pink and works wonders. This produces orange blobs at the side of the nose and a weird shade on the water line, Total waste of money a big Benefit fail.

This is not a good product. The color is peach not pink. It does not cover up redness like the previous eye bright. It is not soft & is actually painful to put on. Please bring back the original eye bright!