Benefit

They're Real! Magnet Extreme Lengthening Mascara Mascara (Full Size)

I received this as a complimentary full size tube of this mascara from Influenster. I will be up front I hate false eyelashes and I am constantly trying new mascara's in an attempt to make my thin, fair lashes look fuller and I can rarely find one I can also use on my lower lashes without making a mess because of the brush. After curling my lashes I applied two coats and my lashes looked thick, full & curled without feeling heavy and clumpy! And to top it off each time I did my lower lashes I had zero issues! I always try a new product for at least 3 weeks straight, with multiple other products to see how it performs before I write a review.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I was skeptical when I first tried my Benefit They're Real magnet mascara. It claims to make your lashes appear 40% longer than usual. The wand brush seems a little stubby to me but I can't complain about my lashes. They do appear longer and I definitely love the color and formula. While my lashes appear longer, they are definitely lacking in volume. I wish when I found a mascara that made my lashes appear longer they would also appear thicker to give the full affect. I did try these a second time with my fake eyelashes and they really set them off. I have other mascaras that perform better for half the cost and will probably stick with them.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] There is definitely a difference between $25+ mascara and $10 mascara. During covid I stopped buying the really good stuff and once I received this I was like why did I stop? This mascara really does lengthen and provide all day volume, no clumps. Doesn't smear off during the day. I can see and feel a difference and it is the type of difference that really feels good! Being on zoom all day, seeing no one really, it feels like enough just to pop this mascara on and feel good to go! It provides that much impact. This is on the more expensive side so I will have to see how long it lasts but after using it a week+ I would look to buy this again.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This mascara was awesome at lifting and lengthening my lashes to new heights!! Not only did my lashes look full and voluminous, they looked soft too and not like spider legs or crunchy like some other mascaras make lashes look. The wand and brush aren't your typical ones either. The brush doesn't collect too much mascara, and you are able to coat every lash to the fullest without too much mascara. I was able to put on 3 coats of this mascara without it looking gross., so it is definitely builadable! I would definitely recommend this mascara to anyone looking for fullness and volume without it looking too much like you have too much mascara on.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I'll admit I was skeptical when I first received this mascara. I've used the original "They're Real!" a few times over the years but the idea of magnets potentially getting in my eyes and the safety of that had me questioning putting it on at all. After using it, I was impressed. It provided decent volume and life comparable to my go-to waterproof Urban Decay mascara and the staying power was there too with minimal flaking toward the end of the day. As someone with oily eyelids, I'm prone to "panda eyes" with most mascaras not marketed as waterproof but this one held up. Is it gimicky? Yes. Does it still deliver on promised results. You betcha!

Really like the wand, didn't have any issues with clumping. Didn't have any fall out or anything get into my eyes. This product is not waterproof. But a great everyday wear mascara.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have mixed feelings about this mascara. My first impressions were "this is awful". However, with more use, I started to warm up to it a bit more. I found that it really is not an extreme lengthening mascara on its own, but it works a little better with a mascara underneath. It's not very buildable without getting clumpy, but one coat with a primer gives a good amount of mascara. It's really difficult to remove, however, and I have to use a makeup remover wash and micellar water to get it off. It doesn't look bad when applied well, but it's not anything special. I've had drugstore mascara that I liked a lot more than this. Would not repurchase.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The regular they're real mascaras is one of my favorites, but this one is even better. I noticed major lengthening when I use this and no clumps whatsoever. I noticed some added volume but not as much as I was expecting. When I'm wearing this mascara is looks like I have beautiful long lashes. My lashes still feel soft and natural when I'm wearing this-not like the hard thick feeling I usually get. This is particularly noticeable when I'm taking off my mascara because I usually feel like I'm about to snap my lashes off, but not when I'm trying to take this off. It comes off easily, but even so it doesn't even flake doe smudge throughout the day.